Vietnam’s silent bullet

Terrifying study shows jungle parasite from Southeast Asia may be killing American veterans decades after end of the war

Troops of the Ninth division wade through swamps and rivers south of Saigon in the summer of 1969, in the Delta area

Half a century after serving in Vietnam, test results show some men may have been infected by a slow-killing parasite while fighting in the jungles of Southeast Asia.

The Department of Veterans Affairs this spring commissioned a small pilot study to look into the link between liver flukes ingested through raw or undercooked fish and a rare bile duct cancer.

It can take decades for symptoms to appear.

By then, patients are often in tremendous pain, with just a few months to live.

‘It was surprising,’ he said, stressing the preliminary results could include false positives and that the research is ongoing.

Of the 50 blood samples submitted, more than 20 percent came back positive or bordering positive for liver fluke antibodies, said Sung-Tae Hong, the tropical medicine specialist who carried out the tests at Seoul National University in South Korea.

FILE – This combination of file photos provided by their families shows some of the hundreds of U.S. veterans of the Vietnam War who suffered from cholangiocarcinoma, a rare bile duct cancer believed to be linked to liver fluke parasites in raw or poorly cooked river fish. This cancer takes decades to manifest itself. Top row from left are Andrew G. Breczewski, Arthur R. Duhon Sr., Clarence E. Sauer, Dennis Anthony Reinhold, Donald Edward Fiechter, George Jardine, Horst Alexander Koslowsky, Hugo Rocha and James Robert Zimmerman. Second row from left are James Vincent Kondreck, John J. Skahill Jr., Johnny Herald, Leonard H. Chubb, Louis A. DiPietro, Mario Petitti, Mark M. Lipman, Marvin H. Edwards and Michael Kimmons. Third row from left are Mike Brown, Paul Smith, Pete Harrison, Peter D. Antoine, Ralph E. Black, Ricardo Ortiz Jr., Richard Anthony Munoz, Robert J. Fossett Jr. and Robert L. Boring. Fourth row from left are Robert Lee Phelps, Ronald Lee Whitman, Thomas F. Brock, Thomas Michael Cambron, Thomas R. Kitchen Jr., W. Roy Leuenberger, Wayne Lagimoniere, William Boleslaw Klimek and William Francis Hanlon Jr. (AP Photo)

Preserved liver fluke parasites at the Siriraj Hospital in Bangkok, Thailand (pictured: Sept. 7, 2016)

Cholangiocarcinoma is a rare bile duct cancer that the VA believes may be killing Vietnam veterans. Troops are seen above fighting during the war

Northport VA Medical Center spokesman Christopher Goodman confirmed the New York facility collected the samples and sent them to the lab.

He would not comment on the findings, but said everyone who tested positive was notified.

Gerry Wiggins, who served in Vietnam from 1968 to 1969, has already lost friends to the disease. He was among those who got the call.

Disease’s origins are believed to stem from ingesting raw or undercooked fish. Pictured, engineers from the 173rd Air Cavalry make their way through forest on Chu Phong mountain, in the Ida Drang Valley, Vietnam, 1965

Small pilot study comissioned by the VA found out of 50 veterans tested, 20 per cent were positive. Seen above, troops of the Ninth division wade through swamps and rivers south of Saigon in the summer of 1969, in the Delta area

‘I was in a state of shock,’ he said. ‘I didn’t think it would be me.’

The 69-year-old, who lives in Port Jefferson Station, New York, didn’t have any symptoms when he agreed to take part in the study, but hoped his participation could help save lives.

He immediately scheduled further tests, discovering he had two cysts on his bile duct, which had the potential to develop into the cancer, known as cholangiocarcinoma. They have since been removed and – for now – he’s doing well.

Though rarely found in Americans, the parasites infect an estimated 25 million people worldwide.

Endemic in the rivers of Vietnam, the worms can easily be wiped out with a handful of pills early on, but left untreated they can live for decades without making their hosts sick.

Over time, swelling and inflammation of the bile duct can lead to cancer. Jaundice, itchy skin, weight loss and other symptoms appear only when the disease is in its final stages.

The VA study, along with a call by Senate Minority Leader Charles Schumer of New York for broader research into liver flukes and cancer-stricken veterans, began after The Associated Press raised the issue in a story last year.

The reporting found that about 700 veterans with cholangiocarcinoma have been seen by the VA in the past 15 years.

It can take decades for symptoms to appear and by then, patients are often in tremendous pain with just a few months to live. Pictured, American and South Vietnam soldiers crossing a river during the war in 1963

Less than half of them submitted claims for service-related benefits, mostly because they were not aware of a possible connection to Vietnam.

The VA rejected 80 percent of the requests, but decisions often appeared to be haphazard or contradictory, depending on what desks they landed on, the AP found.

The numbers of claims submitted reached 60 in 2017, up from 41 last year.

Nearly three out of four of those cases were also denied, even though the government posted a warning on its website this year saying veterans who ate raw or under-cooked freshwater fish while in Vietnam might be at risk.

It stopped short of urging them to get ultrasounds or other tests, saying there was currently no evidence the vets had higher infection rates than the general population.

Paratroopers of the 173rd Airborne Brigade keep lookout during a rest while on patrol for Viet Cong. Paratroopers in the foreground carry M-16 demolition packs

‘We are taking this seriously,’ said Curt Cashour, a spokesman with the Department of Veterans Affairs. ‘But until further research, a recommendation cannot be made either way.’

Veteran Mike Baughman, 65, who was featured in the previous AP article, said his claim was granted early this year after being denied three times.

He said the approval came right after his doctor wrote a letter saying his bile duct cancer was ‘more likely than not’ caused by liver flukes from the uncooked fish he and his unit in Vietnam ate when they ran out of rations in the jungle.

He now gets about $3,100 a month and says he’s relieved to know his wife will continue to receive benefits after he dies. But he remains angry that other veterans’ last days are consumed by fighting the same government they went to war for as young men.

‘In the best of all worlds, if you came down with cholangiocarcinoma, just like Agent Orange, you automatically were in,’ he said, referring to benefits granted to veterans exposed to the toxic defoliant sprayed in Vietnam. ‘You didn’t have to go fighting.’

In this Oct. 12, 2017 photo, Mike Baughman, center, plays the bass with Sam Gibson, left, on guitar while Ryan Baughman, right, looks on at a cabin in Herald, W.Va

Baughman, who is thin and weak, recently plucked out ‘Country Roads’ on a bass during a jam session at his cabin in West Virginia.

He wishes the VA would do more to raise awareness about liver flukes and to encourage Vietnam veterans to get an ultrasound that can detect inflammation.

‘Personally, I got what I needed, but if you look at the bigger picture with all these other veterans, they don’t know what necessarily to do,’ he said. ‘None of them have even heard of it before. A lot of them give me that blank stare like, ‘You’ve got what?”

Written for the Associated Press and published by the Daily Mail ~ November 22, 2017.

FAIR USE NOTICE: This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U. S. C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml

3 thoughts on “Vietnam’s silent bullet

  1. Mark

    So here I am at 68 remembering the few times I ate food given to me by Vietnamese villagers (Christians we were protecting) and also sharing a few meals with some Puffs at an outpost. Can’t remember what it was, but I do remember after existing on nothing but C-Rats their food was delicious. Glad I didn’t eat more.

    After starting to read the Agent Orange story in “An Army Waiting to Die” years ago I couldn’t get through it…to many of us were killed in Nam and didn’t know it…this latest possibility is disturbing.

    Reply
  2. John Slagle

    Thanks for your service Mark, and to all veterans past and present Happy Thanksgiving. 20 some years ago, at the V.V.A. 106 meetings in Tucson, we had several Navy Swift Boat crewmen who patrolled the rivers of Vietnam and also caught fish to supplement rations. Marines and former soldiers also spoke of eating raw fish saturated with 33 bom-bom sauce or Tabasco when available. Reading this article, I wonder how many of those veterans are still alive today.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *